The original Franks Memo from Richard Allen's defense was a huge document. It triggered a lot of discussion, and is arguably the most important turning point in the case. As we approach Richard Allen's trial, it's important that the information in the Memo is looked at with fresh eyes. 

The first Franks Memo named five individuals who could be responsible for the murders. Here we look at those five individuals again, and summarize the reasons RA's defense pointed the finger at them.

Brad Holder: A Friend with Dark Ties

Evidence:

  • Social Media Disappearance: Holder's abrupt disappearance from social media following the murders raises eyebrows, especially considering his close ties to Patrick Westfall.
  • Symbolism: The eerie resemblance of a rune symbol on Holder's hand to one found on Abby's body raises chilling questions.
  • Disturbing Posts: Suspicious social media activity, including posts referencing "half-dead women" and a fascination with Gothic figures, hint at a disturbing mindset.
  • Alibi Concerns: Questions linger over the adequacy of Holder's alibi at Liberty Landfill, which warrants further investigation.

Connection to Elvis Fields:

  • Social Media Mimicry: Fields' emulation of Holder's posts on social media suggests a possible connection and shared interests.
  • Personal Connection: Holder's son's relationship with Abby Williams adds a personal dimension to the suspicion surrounding him.

Patrick Westfall: A Missing Piece of the Puzzle

Evidence:

  • Close Association: Westfall's close friendship with Holder and subsequent disappearance from social media align him closely with the case.
  • Ritualistic Behavior: Allegations of involvement in a ritual with Holder in the woods, coupled with proximity to the crime scene, paint a concerning picture.
  • Incriminating Posts: A Facebook post depicting Westfall carving runes into tree limbs reminiscent of those found at the crime scene raises significant red flags.

Connection to Brad Holder:

  • Religious Ties: Participation in Asatru religious ceremonies alongside Holder deepens the connection between the two friends.
  • Potential Conflict: A reported rift over a ritual in the woods hints at underlying tensions that could have escalated.

Elvis Fields: A Troubled Confession

Evidence:

  • Confession: Fields' confession to his sisters, coupled with intimate crime scene details, positions him squarely as a suspect.
  • Physical Resemblance: The resemblance between Fields and a sketch of a man near the crime scene further intensifies scrutiny.
  • Influence Suspicions: Fields' mental state and alleged susceptibility to Holder's influence raise questions about his culpability.

Connection to Brad Holder:

  • Familial Connection: Holder's son's relationship with Abby Williams establishes a direct link between Fields and the victims.
  • Possible Grooming: Speculation about Holder grooming Fields for involvement in the crime adds layers to the investigation.

Johnny Messer: The Gang Connection

Evidence:

  • Gang Affiliation: Messer's ties to the Vinlander gang, along with connections to other suspects, position him within the realm of suspicion.
  • Unexplained Blood: The discovery of Messer's vehicle with unexplained blood in Delphi around the time of the murders raises significant concerns.

Connection to Brad Holder:

  • Gang Affiliation: Shared associations with Holder through Vinlander connections suggest potential collaboration or recruitment.

Rod Abrams: Concealed Complicity?

Evidence:

  • Deception: Abrams' deceit regarding his whereabouts on the day of the murders raises suspicions about his involvement.
  • Concealed Communications: Refusal to allow examination of his phone for communications with Fields raises red flags about potential collaboration.

Connection to Elvis Fields:

  • Friendship: Abrams' friendship with Fields suggests a possible connection to the crimes, especially considering his reluctance to cooperate with authorities.