The good folks at Defense Diaries, The Unravelling, as well as Cara Wieneke spent their own money securing the court transcript for the 18 March hearing on Defense's Motion to Dismiss (Exculpatory Evidence). A huge hat-tip to them for doing this, and I hope we can find ways to fund similar initiative in future.

Last night Bob and Ali Motta of Defense Diaries held a reading of the entire transcript on their YouTube Channel (Defense Diaries on Youtube). Revelations from the court hearing on the 3/18 Motion to Dismiss have shed new light on the case, unveiling potentially crucial evidence that challenges the prosecution's narrative.

I can't help but feel that if the Jury in Allen's trial hears this same evidence, they will be forced to acquit Richard, because it is so compelling. It's especially compelling considering its source: a veteran police officer with first-hand knowledge of how the Delphi Murders investigation was carried out. I want to say it here and now: Todd Click is a hero for doing this in the name of justice. At least one of his colleagues was murdered in the course of this investigation, and in the tense and dangerous world of Indiana law enforcement and some of the corrupt elements surrounding this case, he is genuinely risking his life.

Here are some key takeaways from the transcript.

Key Points and Incriminating Evidence:

  • Missing Audio Evidence: Defense attorney Andrew Baldwin highlighted the absence of critical audio evidence, which could potentially implicate Elvis Fields in the murders. This missing evidence suggests a possible oversight or negligence in the investigation process.
  • Fields' Alleged Statements: Elvis Fields purportedly made several admissions that could link him to the crimes. He allegedly told Detective Murphy that if his spit were found on one of the victims, he had a reason for it. This statement strongly implies Fields' involvement or awareness of the crime scene. Additionally, Fields allegedly confessed to his sister, Mary Abrams, admitting to "having done something bad to some girls." He also allegedly described placing sticks in a victim's hair and claimed to be part of a gang with a brother. These statements provide compelling circumstantial evidence of Fields' guilt.

Primary Insights:

  • Significance of Fields' Admissions: The defense argues that Fields' admissions to both Detective Murphy and his sister, Mary Abrams, serve as crucial evidence linking him to the murders. These statements, if proven to be true, establish a direct connection between Fields and the crimes.
  • Failure to Obtain Search Warrant: Despite the compelling nature of Fields' admissions, law enforcement failed to obtain a search warrant for Fields' residence. This failure raises questions about the thoroughness of the investigation and suggests a potential oversight on the part of law enforcement.

Additional Information:

Detective Ferency, RIP
Detective Ferency, RIP
  • Impact of Detective Ferency's Death: The investigation into Fields' potential involvement stalled following the tragic death of Detective Ferency. Ferency was shot to death by FORMER CORRECTIONS OFFICER Shane Meehan in July 2021. This event significantly impeded the progress of the investigation, leaving crucial leads unexplored. It is unlikely the circumstances of Ferency's murder will ever be known, but it had a chilling effect on a key line of investigation.
  • Letter to Prosecutor's Office: Officer Todd Click, along with other detectives, drafted a letter to the prosecutor's office outlining their findings regarding Fields' potential involvement in the murders. This letter, dated April 28, 2023, underscores the seriousness of the allegations against Fields and the detectives' concerns regarding the direction of the investigation.

Relevant Quotes:

  • Defense Attorney Baldwin emphasized the importance of Fields' alleged admissions, stating, "If his spit was found on one of the victims, he had a reason for it." This quote highlights the potentially incriminating nature of Fields' statements to Detective Murphy.
  • Baldwin also referenced Fields' alleged confession to his sister, Mary Abrams, stating, "He had done something bad to some girls." This quote underscores the gravity of Fields' admissions and their potential significance in the investigation.

It's hard not to be enraged when you read this transcript, and/or consider what it implies. If Judge Gull doesn't prevent this "SODDI" (Some Other Dude Did It) defense into the trial proceedings, I strongly believe it - in and of itself - will be enough to force the Jury to acquit Richard Allen.